Published on
December 18, 2024
It’s not uncommon to have difficulty differentiating between the main financial professionals. Not only are the names similar, but they are also often unintentionally used interchangeably. However, despite how the titles may be used colloquially, there are distinct differences in knowledge, background, and expertise between Bookkeepers, Accountants, CPAs, Controllers, and CFOs.
Your business financials are important. They keep your company in business, pay your employees, and fuel your growth and success. Making a mistake in hiring financial experts to manage your company’s finances—such as hiring someone underqualified to oversee financial strategy or overqualified for general account management—can mean mistakes, missed opportunities, and wasted time and money.
A good way to think about it is like this: you wouldn’t get the vehicle’s transmission replaced or your fuel injector repaired at a quick-lube shop. While there may be individuals there that might have knowledge about these repairs—and might charge less than a full-service mechanic—their expertise day-in and day-out is in quick lube, and hiring them for a more specialized, complicated repair can mean a greater risk and could lead to more expensive repairs down the road. Conversely, going to a high-performance specialty shop for an oil change or to refill your windshield wiper fluid would be effective but much more expensive.
Instead, car owners go to the shop that fits the needs and goals of their service as well as the complexity and performance of their vehicle—whether that’s a quick lube shop for basic oil changes for the family SUV or a high-performance specialty mechanic for a racing import.
In business, the same differentiation holds true. It’s important to understand the differences between financial experts and their roles and responsibilities to determine which fit your financial needs and the current performance and complexity of your company. This way, when you need to make a financial hire, you can be confident that you are looking for the right kind of expert.
The most common professional financial experts are Bookkeepers, Accountants, CPAs, Controllers, and CFOs. While there are some skills and duties that overlap, each of these financial professionals has different levels of experience and education as well as specializing in different areas of expertise.
A bookkeeper is in charge of recording financial transactions and keeping the books up-to-date, as the title suggests. Bookkeepers are generally in charge of payroll, processing financial transactions, reconciling accounts, managing accounts receivable and accounts payable, and preparing initial financial statements.
Bookkeepers typically have at least an associate’s or bachelor’s degree in accounting. Their primary function is to ensure all financial data is accurately recorded and organized. For small businesses, bookkeepers are often the go-to professionals for managing daily financial operations. However, it’s essential to note that while they are skilled in maintaining records, they may lack the advanced training or certifications required to perform complex financial analysis or strategic planning.
For instance, imagine a small retail store with a steady influx of daily sales. A bookkeeper ensures that every transaction is recorded, payments to vendors are made on time, and payroll is processed without errors. This foundational work creates the base for further financial analysis by higher-level professionals.
While an accountant is qualified to perform bookkeeping tasks, they’re generally more experienced in report preparation and interpretation than bookkeepers. Accountants typically have a bachelor’s degree in accounting. They’re typically experienced in bookkeeping, maintaining business accounts, and helping prepare simple tax returns.
Accountants play a more analytical role. They use the data maintained by bookkeepers to prepare financial reports that provide insights into a business’s financial health. This can include income statements, balance sheets, and cash flow statements. These reports help business owners make informed decisions about budgeting, expenses, and investments.
For example, a mid-sized manufacturing company might rely on an accountant to prepare quarterly financial reports to assess profitability and identify cost-saving opportunities. Accountants can also provide advice on tax planning, ensuring businesses take advantage of available deductions and comply with regulations.
While all CPAs are accountants, not all accountants are CPAs. CPAs have met specific state and education licensing requirements and passed the CPA exam. CPAs are considered fiduciaries to their clients, meaning they have a legal duty and power to act on behalf of and in the best interest of their clients. They’re also more experienced in tax code and strategy. In addition, only a CPA can prepare an audited or reviewed financial statement.
CPAs are often sought after for their expertise in tax preparation, audits, and financial planning. They are equipped to handle complex financial situations, such as mergers and acquisitions, estate planning, and litigation support. Businesses undergoing audits or seeking to secure loans from investors often require the services of a CPA to provide credibility and accuracy to financial documents.
Consider a scenario where a growing tech startup seeks venture capital funding. A CPA can help prepare audited financial statements that investors trust, increasing the likelihood of securing the necessary funding. CPAs are also invaluable during tax season, especially for businesses with intricate financial structures or international operations.
A financial controller oversees accounting allocations, reporting, and cash management. It’s wise to have a separation of duties between accountants and controllers so there is a checks and balances system. A controller is also in charge of the internal controls over accounting and financial systems.
The controller will likely oversee negotiating lines of credit and vendor agreements, as well as reviewing financial contracts. Lastly, the controller oversees the preparation of financial statements, as well as budgeting, budget-to-actuals, and basic financial projections.
Controllers act as the bridge between day-to-day financial operations and high-level financial strategy. They ensure that all financial processes align with the company’s goals and maintain compliance with regulatory requirements. In larger organizations, the controller works closely with department heads to ensure budgets are adhered to and financial risks are minimized.
For example, a manufacturing company with multiple production facilities might rely on a controller to manage cash flow, oversee cost accounting, and develop financial forecasts that guide operational decisions. Their role is critical in maintaining financial stability and ensuring resources are allocated efficiently.
The Chief Financial Officer, or CFO, should be, as the name states, the primary C-suite officer over all things financial. CFOs are high-level strategic experts. Unlike the previous roles that are “rear-facing,” meaning they are in charge of record-keeping and day-to-day finances, a CFO is forward-facing.
CFOs are experienced, high-level financial strategists. This senior executive oversees all financial actions and strategies within a company. While other financial roles are typically concerned with historical and present-day finances, a CFO is interested in the future. A CFO will analyze a company’s financial strengths and weaknesses and plan and execute strategies to maximize opportunities and positive outcomes.
CFOs are also in charge of forecasting, systems (financial systems as well as operational systems, including costs and ensuring every branch of the company is integrated into tracking and financial systems), troubleshooting challenges, or opportunities such as raising funds or mergers and acquisitions (M&As).
For example, a multinational corporation planning an acquisition might rely on a CFO to analyze the target company’s financials, assess risks, and develop a strategy for integrating operations. The CFO’s role extends beyond financial management to include leadership in decision-making, collaboration with other executives, and ensuring the company’s long-term financial success.
Understanding the distinctions between these financial roles is crucial for making informed hiring decisions. Small businesses might only need a bookkeeper or accountant to manage daily financial operations, while larger companies require the expertise of controllers or CFOs to navigate complex financial landscapes.
When deciding which financial professional to hire, consider the size and complexity of your business, as well as your short- and long-term financial goals. Hiring the right expert can mean the difference between financial stability and missed opportunities. By aligning your business’s needs with the appropriate financial expertise, you can set the stage for sustainable growth and success.
Need help or assistance? Our team is standing by to make sure you get the help you need. Whether you need to grow or exit your business, we're ready to help!
